PROJECT OVERVIEW


Payroll

Payroll enables business owners to run scheduled team payments directly in FreshBooks.

Payroll

RELEASES


Payroll Evolution

As of 2026, FreshBooks has launched three major Payroll releases, and I led the design and UX research across all three.

This case study focuses primarily on the foundational work behind the 2024 launch, with a deeper look at the strategy, research, and design decisions that shaped the product. It also highlights how the experience evolved through subsequent releases.

  • 2024: Regular Employee Payroll, Payroll Journal Report

  • 2025: Contractor Payroll

  • 2026 (Latest): Off-Cycle Employee Payroll

PROBLEM DEFINITION


Payroll Disconnected from Accounting

From the start, FreshBooks offered a seamless way to pay contractors within the platform. Contractors could invoice business owners, receive payment through FreshBooks Payments, and have transactions automatically reflected in the books.

Employee payroll, however, remained outside the platform. Because employee wages, taxes, and deductions aren’t invoice-based transactions, businesses had to manage payroll through a separate system. For businesses with both employees and contractors, this meant managing workforce payments across two different workflows.

This created a fragmented financial experience, increasing reconciliation effort and limiting FreshBooks’ visibility into one of a business’s largest recurring expenses. It also left a gap in FreshBooks’ vision of being an all-in-one financial platform for small and medium-sized businesses.

Key Problems

  • Fragmented workforce payments: Business owners could pay contractors in FreshBooks but had to use a separate system for employee payroll.

  • Disconnected payroll and accounting: Employee payroll data and expenses lived outside FreshBooks, creating manual reconciliation and potential errors.

  • Incomplete financial visibility: Payroll expenses were not part of FreshBooks’ complete, real-time view of the business.

UX STRATEGY


UX Strategy

Vision

A platform where business owners can confidently manage their team, pay both employees and contractors accurately, and gain clear financial insight as their business grows.

Goal

Drive adoption, engagement, retention and task success of payroll within FreshBooks by making it the default way to pay employees and contractors.

Plan

Reduce payroll complexity by simplifying setup, payroll runs, and payment tracking, enabling business owners to manage employee and contractor compensation seamlessly within FreshBooks.

DESIGN PROCESS


Design Process

I led the end-to-end user research and design process for all three FreshBooks Payroll releases to create a user-centered experience for FreshBooks customers, aligned with key business goals.

User Research

  • User interviews (2024)

  • Journey map (2024)

  • Competitive analysis (2024)

  • Usability testing (2024, 2025)

Design

  • User flows (all releases)

  • Wireframes (all releases)

  • High-fidelity design/prototype (all releases)

  • Final design (all releases)

  • Design handoff (all releases)

USER RESEARCH


User Interviews

For the 2024 release, I interviewed 10 participants using the laddering technique to uncover their underlying needs and motivations around payroll. Most shared that payroll is not their area of expertise and preferred a system that could handle the process end-to-end within FreshBooks.

Overall, payroll was perceived as complex and typically managed through external tools. While business owners wanted to remain largely “hands-off” with administrative work, they still valued visibility and control over payroll runs. They also expressed a strong preference to avoid switching between systems, favoring a single, organized platform for managing both accounting and payroll.

Note: to protect the identities of participants, generic images/names are used here.

Journey Map

I created a journey map that visualizes the previous run payroll workflow, highlighting key experience gaps, pain points, and user goals.

Competitive Analysis

Competitive analysis showed that most competitors already offer payroll in their core markets, signaling a clear industry shift toward integrated payroll solutions.

DESIGN


User Flow

Running payroll can be complex, but this user flow demonstrates how I simplified and streamlined the process.

Wireframes

While iterating, I’ve mostly explored information architecture and navigation, by reducing complexity with the goal to create a seamless experience.

USER RESEARCH


Usability Testing (2024)

For the 2024 release (Regular Employee Payroll), I conducted moderated usability testing with 5 participants from diverse user segments, using a prototype to test two tasks:

  1. Run Regular Employee Payroll

  2. Find the Payroll Run

Qualitative Findings

Positive Feedback

  • 4 of 5 participants described the user flows as “easy” and “smooth”, highlighting its clarity and simplicity

  • It met their expectations for how payroll should work

Neutral/Negative Feedback

  • 1 of 5 participants expressed a need to set custom pay period dates in Step 1

  • 1 of 5 participants experienced friction understanding the payroll statuses (“Submitted” and “Processing”) on the Payroll page

Quantitative Findings

  • The design achieved a high task success rate, with 4 out of 5 participants completing both tasks accurately and efficiently

    • 1 participant was unable to complete Task 1 after getting stuck at Step 1

  • Satisfaction scores were high (4.6/5), indicating that participants perceived the new experience as a meaningful improvement

Usability Testing (2025)

In 2025, I followed the same approach to run moderated usability testing for the new Contractor Payroll feature with 6 participants (4 existing Payroll users and 2 FreshBooks users who hadn’t used Payroll). I created a prototype with two tasks:

  1. Run Contractor Payroll

  2. Find the Payroll Run

Qualitative Findings

Positive Feedback

  • 4 of 6 participants described the flows as “straightforward” and “intuitive”

  • The experience felt like a natural progression from the previous Payroll release

  • Participants praised the option to pay contractors within FreshBooks Payroll

Neutral/Negative Feedback

  • 1 of 6 participants (new to Payroll) questioned why Pay Date is Step 1, before seeing information such as the list of contractors

  • 1 of 6 participants (new to Payroll) questioned why Hours, Wage, and Pay were automatically set to 0 in Step 2

Quantitative Findings

  • The design achieved a high task success rate, with 5 of 6 participants completing both tasks

    • 1 participant was unable to complete Task 1 because they didn’t understand how to add information such as Hours and Bonus in Step 2

  • Satisfaction scores were high (4.4/5), indicating that participants perceived the new experience as a meaningful improvement over how they previously paid contractors

SOLUTION


Payroll Simplified

FreshBooks Payroll is a payroll solution available to U.S. customers as an add-on to FreshBooks subscriptions, offered across Lite, Plus, Premium, and Select plans (with a free first month included).

It enables unlimited payroll runs for employees (regular and off-cycle) and contractors, automatic tax filing and payments, direct deposit, and generation of tax forms (W-2s). Each payroll run is automatically recorded in the platform, ensuring financial reports and bookkeeping remain accurate and up to date.

Key Improvements

  • Single platform experience: Business owners can now manage payroll for both employees and contractors within FreshBooks without switching tools.

  • Simplified payroll workflows: Employee onboarding, payroll setup, and pay runs are streamlined into an intuitive, end-to-end process.

  • Connected payroll and accounting: Payroll transactions are automatically recorded in FreshBooks, reducing reconciliation effort and potential errors.

  • Complete financial visibility: Payroll is reflected in real time, giving business owners a complete view of their business finances.

DESIGN


Final Design

After aligning with the team on the solution, I finalized end-to-end flows for Set Up, the Payroll page, Run Payroll, the Payroll Journal Report, and Settings.

For the Run Payroll flow, I minimized cognitive load and streamlined the process by leveraging progressive disclosure and prepopulating key information (such as employees, pay rates, hours, taxes, and payment methods) based on setup data.

To see the design in a greater detail, you can view the prototype.

Note: the prototype has limited functionality.

Design System

I redesigned the table component to remove the legacy four-column limit, enabling flexible, scalable layouts that surface more information as needed. It's now used across the Payroll page and throughout the Run Payroll flow.

Additionally, I’ve contributed to the iconography by designing feature-specific icons that help users identify actions and navigate the interface more intuitively.

Accessibility

By pushing back on the use of a hover-based Quick Actions menu in the Payment History table that was initially considered (to access actions such as canceling a payroll run or downloading a payroll receipt), I ensured accessibility on touch devices like tablets and phones, where hover interactions aren’t supported.

Design Principles

  • Unfold Like an Onion: Start as simple as possible, and gently reveal information only as it's needed. Where the choice presents itself, complexity should be opt-in. Customers can choose to turn on advanced options.

  • Adapt to the Task: Give frequent tasks priority and keep 'set-it-and-forget-it' tasks out of the way. Implement experiences that acknowledge different volumes; the needs of a customer with 10 Invoices are different than a customer with 1000, adapt the experience to suit each.

  • Maintain Flow: Surface only the options relevant to the task at hand. Enable customers to complete a workflow without leaving the page.

  • Speak Human: Be straightforward yet conversational, it shouldn't sound robotic or impersonal. Don't include jargon, or complicated phrasing. Where complicated terms are required (e.g., Accounting terminology), incorporate in-context help.

  • Set Expectations: Avoid surprises, customers should know what results will come out of their actions and feel in control. Provide customers with insight on where they are in the process and any effect on their clients before they take the action.

  • Don't Add, Evolve: Features should fit into the larger FreshBooks puzzle. Experiences should feel like a natural extension, increasing functionality instead of adding on top. Where a feature relates to another area of FreshBooks, the connection should be obvious.

Challenges and Trade-Offs

Table Constraints

During the initial ideation process for the Payroll page and the Run Payroll flows, I identified that the legacy table component’s four-column limit would not meet user needs and would not scale to support payroll workflows. This concern was later validated through usability testing.

Despite engineering concerns around grid constraints and delivery risk, I advocated for prioritizing validated user needs and long-term product usability over short-term implementation convenience.

Descoping

The original 2024 scope covered three payroll experiences: Regular Employee, Contractor, and Off-Cycle Payroll. Given delivery constraints, my team and I decided to launch with Regular Employee Payroll only, as it addressed the most critical customer need. In the meantime, customers who needed Off-Cycle Payroll could request it through customer support to help bridge the gap.

Contractor and Off-Cycle Payroll were postponed, with Contractor Payroll launching in 2025 and Off-Cycle Payroll in 2026. This phased approach let us build a strong product foundation, learn from real customer adoption and feedback, and use those insights to shape the next releases.

AI USAGE


How I Leveraged AI

Approach

Following FreshBooks’ human-in-the-loop approach to AI, I used tools such as Claude and Condens AI to streamline design and UX research. Here is where I applied AI in each release:

  • 2024: No AI used

  • 2025: Condens AI to synthesize usability testing findings (integrated with UserInterviews.com and Zoom)

  • 2026 (Latest): Claude for ideation (wireframing and prototyping) and final design, connected to our design system through Figma MCP

Output and Quality Standard

For research, Condens AI helped me synthesize the usability testing data, cluster the findings, and draft the research report.

For design, I prompted Claude to wireframe the Run Off-Cycle Payroll flow. Here is the prompt:

Using our design system in Figma, design a wireframe for the Run Off-Cycle Payroll flow in FreshBooks Payroll, for one-time bonuses and corrections. Use the existing 3-step Run Payroll flow and our existing components as the starting point, add payroll type, deductions, and tax withholding choices to Step 1, and prepopulate employee details from setup data.

Claude’s final design output was a good starting point, but it struggled with edge cases. I designed those manually, and reviewed and refined the rest, including spacing, component usage, and content, to meet our quality standard before design handoff.

Pictured below is one of Claude’s wireframe outputs.

Set Up Payroll

Run Regular Employee Payroll

Run Contractor Payroll

Run Off-Cycle Employee Payroll

Payroll Journal Report

IMPACT


KPIs

The new Payroll feature quickly became a core part of the product experience, driving strong adoption, engagement, and retention, along with high task success and positive user sentiment.

40,000+

monthly active users

89%

adoption rate

92%

engagement rate

95%

retention rate

+47

net promoter score

88%

task success

How We Measured Success

  • Adoption rate (89%): Percentage of users who interacted with Payroll after adding it to their subscription (post-launch).

  • Engagement rate (92%): Percentage of active Payroll users performing meaningful actions monthly, such as running payroll and payroll reports.

  • Retention rate (95%): Percentage of users who continued using Payroll month-over-month, based on active Payroll usage.

  • Task success rate (88%): Percentage of users who successfully completed a payroll run each month.

  • NPS (+47): Based on in-app and email surveys (majority of respondents rated 9-10), with feedback highlighting ease of use, speed, and reliability.

Usage metrics were tracked via FullStory, and survey feedback was collected using Pendo. The data is from 2026.

Customer Feedback

“FreshBooks Payroll has been a reliable, efficient and user friendly tool for managing my team's payroll. It simplifies the process, ensures compliance and integrates perfectly with my accounting system.”

Business Owner

PROJECT DETAILS


Project Details

  • Role: Senior Product Designer / UX Researcher

  • Company: FreshBooks

  • Industry: Finance

  • Market: B2B, SaaS

  • Team: Senior Product Designer / UX Researcher (me), Product Manager, Engineering

  • Framework: Agile

  • Tools:

    • Design: Figma, Zeroheight, Miro

    • User research: UserInterviews.com, Condens

    • Project management: Jira, Confluence

    • Product analytics: Fullstory, Pendo, Looker

    • AI: Claude, Condens, Granola

  • Years: 2024, 2025, 2026

  • Platform: Web

  • Link: FreshBooks.com